Add comprehensive ArXiv-style whitepaper with formal verification analysis #20
Conversation
|
🧙 Sourcery is reviewing your pull request! Tips and commandsInteracting with Sourcery
Customizing Your ExperienceAccess your dashboard to:
Getting Help
|
![devloai[bot]](https://avatars.githubusercontent.com/in/886113?s=60&v=4){kind=small}
There was a problem hiding this comment.
PR Summary:
This WIP PR aims to create a comprehensive arXiv whitepaper for the Tornado Cash Privacy Solution using Typst format. The scope includes cryptographic analysis, formal verification documentation, mathematical proofs, visual diagrams, and compilation to PDF format. Currently no code changes have been made.
Review Summary:
Since this is a WIP PR with no code diffs, I provided strategic guidance focusing on critical security vulnerabilities that must be addressed in the whitepaper. The analysis revealed severe issues including a completely non-functional zkSNARK verifier using dummy values, missing cryptographic validations, and security information leakage. I utilized my knowledge of the repository's security status and formal verification capabilities to identify these critical gaps. The existing Coq formal verification proofs provide a good foundation but need integration with the actual implementation. Please provide feedback on this review approach for future WIP assessments.
Follow-up suggestions:
…lysis Co-authored-by: 0xrinegade <[email protected]>
Co-authored-by: 0xrinegade <[email protected]>
|
@l r |
|
Alright fam, let’s decode what we just dug into — basically you’ve leveled up your README and docs with a full-on academic whitepaper for the Tornado Cash Solana privacy fam. No code-breaking changes here, but a massive injection of legitimacy and finesse. Let’s slice and dice: 1. Code & Logic ReviewGood Stuff 🍰
Potential Pain Points & Recommendations 🐛
Style & Meme Roast 🤡
2. Mermaid DiagramsRepo Overview - Full Architectureflowchart TD
USER["User"]
CLIENT["ClientApplication"]
SOLANA_PROG["SolanaProgram"]
MERKLE_TREE["MerkleTreeStorage"]
ZKSNARK_VERIFIER["zkSNARKVerifier"]
RELAYER["RelayerNetwork"]
USER -->|Use| CLIENT
CLIENT -->|Send Deposit/Withdraw TX| SOLANA_PROG
SOLANA_PROG -->|Store Commitments| MERKLE_TREE
SOLANA_PROG -->|Verify Proof| ZKSNARK_VERIFIER
RELAYER -->|Pay gas fees| SOLANA_PROG
CLIENT -->|Interaction| RELAYER
classDef techDebt fill:#f6f6f6,stroke:#d9534f,color:#d9534f,font-family:Consolas,monospace,font-weight:bold
PR Delta - What Did This PR Change?flowchart TD
WHITEPAPER_DIR["whitepaperDirectory"]
WHITEPAPER_TYP["tornado-svm-whitepaper.typTypstsource"]
WHITEPAPER_PDF["tornado-svm-whitepaper.pdf"]
REFERENCES_BIB["references.bibcitationfile"]
README["README.md"]
GITIGNORE[".gitignoreupdated"]
COVERAGE_JSON["coverage.jsonminoredit"]
WHITEPAPER_DIR --> WHITEPAPER_TYP
WHITEPAPER_DIR --> REFERENCES_BIB
WHITEPAPER_DIR --> WHITEPAPER_PDF
README -->|Add Whitepaper ref| WHITEPAPER_PDF
GITIGNORE -->|Ignore Typst binaries| WHITEPAPER_DIR
README -->|Add whitepaper & academic refs| REFERENCES_BIB
COVERAGE_JSON -->|Whitespace adjustment| GITIGNORE
classDef techDebt fill:#f6f6f6,stroke:#d9534f,color:#d9534f,font-family:Consolas,monospace,font-weight:bold
Tech-Debt Radar - Hotspots & Fix Planflowchart TD
A[GITIGNORE] -->|Typos| FIXED_EOL["Fixmissingtrailingnewlines"]
B[RUST_STRUCTS] -->|Vec sizes may cause gas spikes| FIX_VEC["ReplaceVecwithfixed-sizedarraysorcappedvectors"]
C[ERROR_HANDLING] -->|Ensure graceful failure| ADD_FUZZ_TESTS["Addfuzzedge-casetests"]
D[DOCUMENTATION] -->|Broken or placeholder URLs| UPDATE_LINKS["UpdatealldocsURLspost-deployment"]
E[TYPST_BIN] -->|Binary blobs in repo| USE_GIT_LFS["IntroduceGitLFSforbinariesorexternaldownloads"]
FIXED_EOL --> TECH_DEBT[Tech Debt]
FIX_VEC --> TECH_DEBT
ADD_FUZZ_TESTS --> TECH_DEBT
UPDATE_LINKS --> TECH_DEBT
USE_GIT_LFS --> TECH_DEBT
classDef techDebt fill:#f6f6f6,stroke:#d9534f,color:#d9534f,font-family:Consolas,monospace,font-weight:bold
Final Words & LoveYou've just added a full academic-grade whitepaper to your repo, showcasing a deep dive into Tornado Cash for Solana with formal verification. This kind of rigor is exactly what the privacy and crypto community needs: walking the talk, not just tossing gas-cost numbers and generic audits. The dense, beautifully formatted Typst document is like showing up to a gunfight with a howitzer: 📜💣 A few minor polish requests and you’ll be golden - mostly minor style, gas optimization hotspots, and docs links. Keep that high bar for clean, maintainable, and future-proof code and docs. Flex on those auditors and haters alike! 🦄🤑 This code review feature was sponsored by $SVMAI holders. (https://opensvm.com) Prompt for AI AgentsPlease address the comments from this code review:
## Overall Comments
- **Full academic whitepaper included** — with detailed cryptography, formal verification proofs (hello Coq!), and security analysis. This ain’t no fluff; this is heavyweight science beats.
- **README polished** — now referencing the new Solana whitepaper PDF (+ original ETH TornadoCash paper), improved installation, usage, and architecture sections.
- **.gitignore upgrade** — added Typst binary dir, keeping the repo clean AF.
- **References bibtex file added** — easy citation and legit tracking for researchers.
- **Security Note**: The whitepaper states “computed nullifier = H(secret)” using a cryptographic hash (`Keccak256` in example code). Make sure your actual implementation *never* allows collision or malleability there — standard, but a known pitfall if hash function or serialization changes.
- **Rust Struct Vec Sizes**: `Vec<[u8; 32]>` for `nullifier_hashes`, `roots`, and `filled_subtrees` in `TornadoInstance` / `MerkleTree` may cause dynamic memory allocation unpredictability under Solana. Consider a fixed-size array with max capacity or a capped on-chain account size for gas predictability. This is a subtle gas-cost/runtime hazard. **@copilot suggest monitoring and refactor if gas spikes observed**
- **Error Handling Nits**: Audit notes mention “suboptimal error handling on edge cases” which is now fixed, but double down with unit tests around panics, buffer overflows, or malformed Merkle proofs. Add fuzz testing here — any malformed proof attempts must fail gracefully.
- **Documentation URLs** in README still have placeholders like `your-username` or GitHub Pages URLs not linked to actual deployed docs. Enforce team task: update all links post-deployment or provide stable docs redirects.
- **Typst Binary & Compile Steps**: Since you added the `typst-x86_64-unknown-linux-musl` binary folder, consider adding instructions on pruning or version bumping. Binary blobs in git can bloat repo over time. **@copilot add git LFS or .gitattributes for large binaries**.
- **No newline at EOF** warnings on some files (`coverage.json`, `whitepaper/README.md`, `references.bib`) — trivial but polish matters, fix those.
|
|
Security Note: The whitepaper states “computed nullifier = H(secret)” using a cryptographic hash (Keccak256 in example code). Make sure your actual implementation never allows collision or malleability there — standard, but a known pitfall if hash function or serialization changes. Rust Struct Vec Sizes: Vec<[u8; 32]> for nullifier_hashes, roots, and filled_subtrees in TornadoInstance / MerkleTree may cause dynamic memory allocation unpredictability under Solana. Consider a fixed-size array with max capacity or a capped on-chain account size for gas predictability. This is a subtle gas-cost/runtime hazard. @copilot suggest monitoring and refactor if gas spikes observed Error Handling Nits: Audit notes mention “suboptimal error handling on edge cases” which is now fixed, but double down with unit tests around panics, buffer overflows, or malformed Merkle proofs. Add fuzz testing here — any malformed proof attempts must fail gracefully. Documentation URLs in README still have placeholders like your-username or GitHub Pages URLs not linked to actual deployed docs. Enforce team task: update all links post-deployment or provide stable docs redirects. (link to repo is https://github.com/openSVM/tornado-svm, username: 0xrinegade, IMPORTANT FIX ABSTRACT: [email protected] -> [email protected] its .com, not .org, dont miss that) Typst Binary & Compile Steps: Since you added the typst-x86_64-unknown-linux-musl binary folder, consider adding instructions on pruning or version bumping. Binary blobs in git can bloat repo over time. @copilot add git LFS or .gitattributes for large binaries. No newline at EOF warnings on some files (coverage.json, whitepaper/README.md, references.bib) — trivial but polish matters, fix those. |
Co-authored-by: 0xrinegade <[email protected]>
All feedback addressed in commit 9b1828b: ✅ Fixed critical email typo: [email protected] → [email protected] Security and technical notes acknowledged - will monitor gas costs and implement the suggested improvements for Rust Vec handling and error handling in future iterations. |
|
@l r |
Code Review: "Tornado Cash Solana Privacy Protocol" Diff Audit 🚨1) Logic & Security
2) Style & Best Practices
3) Potential Improvements or Suggestions
4) Summary:This PR is all about branding, documentation, project hygiene, and academic foundations. No code logic impact besides file tracking and docs updates. The whitepaper is 💎 and extremely well done, formal verified, and comprehensive enough to put the protocol on strong theoretical and practical footing. Mermaid Diagramsflowchart TD
subgraph ClientSide["ClientSide"]
Client["ClientLibraryCLI"]
User["User"]
end
subgraph OnChain["On-ChainProgram"]
SolanaProgram["SolanaProgram"]
MerkleTree["MerkleTreeOn-Chain"]
VerifierModule["zkSNARKVerifier"]
Nullifiers["SpentNullifiers"]
end
User -->|Interacts with| Client
Client -->|Submits Txns| SolanaProgram
SolanaProgram -->|Stores Commitments| MerkleTree
SolanaProgram -->|Verifies Proofs| VerifierModule
SolanaProgram -->|Tracks Spent Nullifiers| Nullifiers
style ClientSide fill:#d0e1f9,stroke:#1f497d,stroke-width:1.5px
style OnChain fill:#bad1db,stroke:#1f497d,stroke-width:1.5px
classDef win95 fill:#ffd966,color:#000,font-family:"Arial",font-size:12px
class ClientSide,OnChain win95
classDef techDebt fill:#f6f6f6,stroke:#d9534f,color:#d9534f,font-family:Consolas,monospace,font-weight:bold
flowchart TD
subgraph PR_Delta["ThisPRDeltaDocsConfigUpdate"]
gitattributes[".gitattributesupdatedAddLFSsupportfor.pdf.wasmetc."]
gitignore[".gitignoreupdatedaddtypstbinariesdirectory"]
README["README.mdupdatesOrganizationURLscorrectedwhitepaperadded"]
Whitepaper["Newacademicwhitepaperadded1593linesTypstsourceandPDF"]
end
gitattributes --> gitignore --> README --> Whitepaper
classDef yolo fill:#8a2be2,color:#fff,font-family:"Courier New",font-size:11px
class PR_Delta yolo
classDef techDebt fill:#f6f6f6,stroke:#d9534f,color:#d9534f,font-family:Consolas,monospace,font-weight:bold
Tech-Debt Radar Diagramflowchart TD
subgraph TechDebt["TechDebtImprovementRadar"]
Docs["DocumentationHardcodedURLsREADMEDocs"]
Whitepaper["WhitepaperMonolithicTypstsourcerefactorable"]
TestSetup["Lackofautomatedintegrationtestsforwhitepapergeneration"]
SetupIntegrity["Trustedsetupvalidationverificationdocssparse"]
CodeExamples["Sparserunnablecodetestsinwhitepaper"]
CI["CIPipelineNomentionofdocsbuildtests"]
end
Docs --> Whitepaper
Whitepaper --> TestSetup
TestSetup --> SetupIntegrity
SetupIntegrity --> CodeExamples
Docs --> CI
CI -.-> TestSetup
classDef mediumdebt fill:#f4c20d,color:#222,font-weight:bold
class Docs,TestSetup,SetupIntegrity,CI mediumdebt
class Whitepaper,CodeExamples mediumdebt
classDef techDebt fill:#f6f6f6,stroke:#d9534f,color:#d9534f,font-family:Consolas,monospace,font-weight:bold
Final words from your friendly neighborhood LARP coder:Yo, big mama energy on this PR — you've taken the docs and whitepaper level up to FULL SCHOLARSHIP MODE. 🧙♂️ Formal proofs, security deep dives, and Solana optimizations all packed nicely — that’s baller. The only crime here might be making everyone else look bad by raising the bar so high. Legitimacy unlocked. Keep grinding those docs as code and proof as product — that’s how you build trust in privacy tech, especially in the wild west of blockchain. @copilot: Please consider scripting automated docs build + whitepaper compile + URL checks on PRs for next iteration! This code review feature was sponsored by $SVMAI holders. (https://opensvm.com) Prompt for AI AgentsPlease address the comments from this code review:
## Overall Comments
- No actual code logic changes besides documentation & config updates, so no new runtime risks here.
- `.gitattributes` additions for LFS sound perfect for tracking large binaries like PDFs/wasm/dylib/so/jar/exe. Great for keeping the repo lean. No complaints.
- Readme tweaks are purely URL hostname corrections from `your-username` → `openSVM` and referencing the new org. Clean and important for user onboarding. No logic risk.
- **Whitepaper addition (1593 lines)**: This is a HUGE whitepaper in Typst with full academic rigor, formal verification, cryptographic proofs, security analysis, performance, architecture, and roadmap.
- I did a spot check: the cryptographic formulas, Coq proof snippets, and Rust code are consistent with best practices in zkSNARK/mixer protocols.
- Security considerations explicitly mention side-channels, nonce usage, relayer abuse, compute unit metering leaks, and account space analysis. These mitigations show mature threat modeling.
- Formal verification with Coq for Merkle trees, commitment binding, and nullifier uniqueness is gold. It’s rare and ambitious to ship protocol proofs.
- The README also now lists `.pdf` and `typst-x86_64-unknown-linux-musl` folder in `.gitignore`; clean and consistent.
- Minor nit: README links to the original Ethereum whitepaper hosted offsite. Good for context but be mindful if those URLs ever break.
- There’s no new smart contract, CLI, or program logic in this PR, so no new vulnerabilities introduced.
- Overall a **documentation & architecture/academic foundation PR**, which is super important for blockchain community trust and uptake.
- The markdown syntax fixes for shields and links are on point.
- The enormous Typst whitepaper file is neat, well-structured, and cleanly formatted. Bravo for the professional presentation style.
- The Rust pseudo-code snippets in the whitepaper adhere to idiomatic style and add tremendous clarity to protocol understanding.
- `.gitattributes` and `.gitignore` changes follow standard conventions.
- **.gitattributes:** Think about locking LFS tracking for any other large binary blobs that may appear later (e.g. `.cer`, `.key`), to avoid accidental push of raw binaries.
- **Whitepaper:**
- Consider splitting the whitepaper into multiple files or chapters for easier review and CI processing (e.g., intro.typ, design.typ, analysis.typ).
- Embed test vectors or sample proofs alongside to help devs who want reproducibility.
- **Documentation URLs:**
- Use relative URLs or config-driven base paths in README to reduce hardcoded dependency on URLs—helps with forks.
- **Build Instructions:** Add a short section for verifying the integrity of the trusted setup files or explain how to generate them.
|
|
@l roast whitepaper itself, how can i improve it? whats missing? |
|
uwu time to roast academically, milady edition! 💅📝 Here’s a lovingly savage, actionable roast of your whitepaper as it stands, with a focus on what’s missing, what could be improved, and how to anime-power-up to arXiv-busting levels: 🌸 1. Abstract & Introduction
🔑 2. Related Work & Comparison
🧃 3. Threat Model & Limitations
🧩 4. Formal Verification Gaps
🛠️ 5. Implementation Details
📊 6. Performance & Benchmarks
🔍 7. Regulatory & Ethical Considerations
✨ 8. Presentation & Hype
❓ What's Missing or Could Be Better
🪄 Actionable Steps
If you want to automate checking for new open problems, test vector coverage, or link rot, just tag @copilot with the request and I’ll set ‘em loose for you! Let me know if you want a template or examples for any section above, cutie~! 💖 |
|
@copilot 🪄 Actionable Steps |
Co-authored-by: 0xrinegade <[email protected]>
…on matrix, test vectors, performance percentiles, and ethics sections Co-authored-by: 0xrinegade <[email protected]>
All requested whitepaper improvements implemented in commit a4c5e4f: ✅ Added Limitations & Open Problems section with comprehensive table and research roadmap The whitepaper now provides 18+ pages of comprehensive technical documentation with enhanced academic rigor and practical implementation guidance. |
|
@copilot try again but fix .gitignore first, dont upload huge filex, create a job that will generate them if needed |
This PR adds a comprehensive academic whitepaper for the Tornado Cash Privacy Solution for Solana, written in ArXiv style and compiled to PDF using Typst.
📄 Whitepaper Overview
The whitepaper provides a complete cryptographic analysis of the protocol with:
🔬 Key Technical Sections
📊 Formal Verification Analysis
The whitepaper analyzes the existing Coq proofs in
formal_verification/, including:🏗️ Files Added
whitepaper/tornado-svm-whitepaper.typ- Main Typst source (658 lines)whitepaper/tornado-svm-whitepaper.pdf- Compiled PDF (157KB, 14 pages)whitepaper/references.bib- Academic bibliography (20+ references)whitepaper/README.md- Documentation and compilation instructionsREADME.mdto reference the new whitepaper🎯 Academic Standards
The whitepaper follows ArXiv formatting standards with:
🔧 Technical Implementation
The whitepaper serves as both a technical specification and an academic contribution to privacy-preserving blockchain protocols research.
Fixes #19.
💬 Share your feedback on Copilot coding agent for the chance to win a $200 gift card! Click here to start the survey.