OIDC #168
OIDC #168
Conversation
|
Important Review skippedDraft detected. Please check the settings in the CodeRabbit UI or the You can disable this status message by setting the WalkthroughWalkthroughThe recent changes primarily enhance the authentication capabilities of the application by integrating OAuth support. Modifications include updates to the API route registration logic for dynamic OAuth provider inclusion based on environment variables. The database schema has been updated to include a new "oauths" table, and the user model has been adjusted to accommodate OAuth relationships. Additionally, various dependencies have been updated to ensure compatibility and functionality with the new features. Changes
Sequence Diagram(s)sequenceDiagram
participant User
participant API
participant OAuthProvider
participant Database
User->>API: Initiate login
API->>OAuthProvider: Check for OAuth provider
OAuthProvider-->>API: Provider available
API->>Database: Create/Update user with OAuth data
Database-->>API: Confirm user creation/update
API-->>User: Return authentication result
Assessment against linked issues
Possibly related PRs
Security Recommendations
Thanks for using CodeRabbit! It's free for OSS, and your support helps us grow. If you like it, consider giving us a shout-out. 🪧 TipsChatThere are 3 ways to chat with CodeRabbit:
SupportNeed help? Create a ticket on our support page for assistance with any issues or questions. Note: Be mindful of the bot's finite context window. It's strongly recommended to break down tasks such as reading entire modules into smaller chunks. For a focused discussion, use review comments to chat about specific files and their changes, instead of using the PR comments. CodeRabbit Commands (Invoked using PR comments)
Other keywords and placeholders
CodeRabbit Configuration File (
|
![coderabbitai[bot]](https://avatars.githubusercontent.com/in/347564?s=60&v=4){kind=small}
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Caution
Inline review comments failed to post
Actionable comments posted: 10
Outside diff range, codebase verification and nitpick comments (6)
backend/app/api/providers/extractors.go (1)
58-94: Ensure consistency in error messages.While the function is robust, consider making error messages consistent in style and detail.
// Example consistent error message return oauthForm, errors.New("failed to parse OAuth form: invalid content type")backend/internal/core/services/service_oauth.go (1)
120-173: Review User Registration Logic inCreateUserThe method handles user registration and group assignment. Ensure that the logic for creating groups and assigning roles is secure and follows best practices. Consider adding role-based access control checks.
// Consider implementing role-based access control for user creationbackend/internal/data/ent/oauth.go (2)
17-35: Review OAuth Entity StructureThe
OAuthentity is well-defined with fields for provider and subject. Ensure that theProviderandSubfields are indexed for efficient querying, especially if they are frequently used in lookups.// Consider adding indexes to the Provider and Sub fields for better query performance
46-57: Enhance Error Messages inUserOrErrMethodThe error messages returned when edges are not loaded or found could be more descriptive to aid in debugging and understanding the context of the error.
return nil, &NotLoadedError{edge: "user", message: "User edge not loaded or found"}backend/internal/data/ent/user_create.go (2)
193-197: Ensure OAuth ID ValidationThe
AddOauthIDsmethod currently lacks explicit validation to ensure that the OAuth IDs correspond to existing entities in the database. It is advisable to implement a validation mechanism to verify the existence of these IDs before adding them. This will enhance the robustness and reliability of the system.
- Consider adding a check to confirm that each OAuth ID exists in the database before calling
AddOauthIDs.Analysis chain
OAuth ID Addition Logic.
The
AddOauthIDsmethod adds OAuth relationships by ID. Confirm that IDs are validated and correspond to existing OAuth entities.Scripts executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Description: Verify that OAuth IDs are validated before being added. # Test: Search for `AddOauthIDs` usage. Expect: Validation logic in place. rg --type go 'AddOauthIDs'Length of output: 1308
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Search for all instances where AddOauthIDs is called and examine the surrounding code for validation logic. rg --type go 'AddOauthIDs' -A 5 -B 5Length of output: 5437
199-206: OAuth Entity Validation Missing.The
AddOauthandAddOauthIDsmethods do not currently include validation logic for OAuth entities. It is advisable to implement validation to ensure these entities are properly initialized before being added.
- Consider adding validation logic within the
AddOauthmethod or before calling it to ensure OAuth entities are valid.Analysis chain
OAuth Entity Addition Logic.
The
AddOauthmethod adds OAuth entities directly. Ensure that these entities are properly initialized and validated.Scripts executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Description: Verify that OAuth entities are validated before being added. # Test: Search for `AddOauth` usage. Expect: Validation logic in place. rg --type go 'AddOauth'Length of output: 1900
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Description: Search for the implementation of AddOauth and AddOauthIDs methods to check for validation logic. # Search for the AddOauth method implementation in user_create.go ast-grep --lang go --pattern $'func (uc *UserCreate) AddOauth(o ...*OAuth) *UserCreate { $$$ }' # Search for the AddOauthIDs method implementation in user_create.go ast-grep --lang go --pattern $'func (uc *UserCreate) AddOauthIDs(ids ...uuid.UUID) *UserCreate { $$$ }'Length of output: 979
Review details
Configuration used: CodeRabbit UI
Review profile: CHILL
Files ignored due to path filters (2)
backend/go.sumis excluded by!**/*.sumbackend/internal/data/migrations/migrations/atlas.sumis excluded by!**/*.sum
Files selected for processing (37)
- backend/app/api/providers/extractors.go (2 hunks)
- backend/app/api/providers/oauth.go (1 hunks)
- backend/app/api/routes.go (3 hunks)
- backend/go.mod (5 hunks)
- backend/internal/core/services/all.go (2 hunks)
- backend/internal/core/services/service_oauth.go (1 hunks)
- backend/internal/core/services/service_user.go (1 hunks)
- backend/internal/core/services/service_user_defaults.go (2 hunks)
- backend/internal/data/ent/client.go (11 hunks)
- backend/internal/data/ent/ent.go (2 hunks)
- backend/internal/data/ent/has_id.go (1 hunks)
- backend/internal/data/ent/hook/hook.go (1 hunks)
- backend/internal/data/ent/migrate/schema.go (3 hunks)
- backend/internal/data/ent/mutation.go (15 hunks)
- backend/internal/data/ent/oauth.go (1 hunks)
- backend/internal/data/ent/oauth/oauth.go (1 hunks)
- backend/internal/data/ent/oauth/where.go (1 hunks)
- backend/internal/data/ent/oauth_create.go (1 hunks)
- backend/internal/data/ent/oauth_delete.go (1 hunks)
- backend/internal/data/ent/oauth_query.go (1 hunks)
- backend/internal/data/ent/oauth_update.go (1 hunks)
- backend/internal/data/ent/predicate/predicate.go (1 hunks)
- backend/internal/data/ent/runtime.go (2 hunks)
- backend/internal/data/ent/schema/oauth.go (1 hunks)
- backend/internal/data/ent/schema/user.go (2 hunks)
- backend/internal/data/ent/tx.go (2 hunks)
- backend/internal/data/ent/user.go (3 hunks)
- backend/internal/data/ent/user/user.go (4 hunks)
- backend/internal/data/ent/user/where.go (2 hunks)
- backend/internal/data/ent/user_create.go (5 hunks)
- backend/internal/data/ent/user_query.go (8 hunks)
- backend/internal/data/ent/user_update.go (11 hunks)
- backend/internal/data/migrations/migrations/20240811221935_oidc.sql (1 hunks)
- backend/internal/data/repo/repo_group.go (1 hunks)
- backend/internal/data/repo/repo_oauth.go (1 hunks)
- backend/internal/data/repo/repo_users.go (1 hunks)
- backend/internal/data/repo/repos_all.go (2 hunks)
Files skipped from review due to trivial changes (3)
- backend/internal/data/ent/oauth/oauth.go
- backend/internal/data/ent/oauth_query.go
- backend/internal/data/repo/repo_users.go
Additional comments not posted (171)
backend/internal/data/ent/schema/oauth.go (5)
3-9: Imports are appropriate.The imported packages are essential for defining the schema and utilizing ent features.
15-19: Mixin usage is correct.The
BaseMixinis appropriately included, likely adding common fields or functionality.
21-27: Field definitions are sound.The fields
providerandsubare necessary for OAuth and correctly specified asNotEmpty.
30-35: Edge definition is accurate.The edge from
OAuthtoUseris correctly defined as unique, indicating a one-to-one relationship.
38-41: Index definition is appropriate.The index on
providerandsubfields ensures uniqueness and efficient querying.backend/internal/data/ent/has_id.go (1)
55-57: GetID method implementation is consistent.The
GetIDmethod forOAuthis correctly implemented, aligning with similar methods for other entities.backend/internal/data/repo/repos_all.go (2)
12-12: AllRepos struct modification is logical.The addition of the
OAuthfield enhances the repository's ability to manage OAuth operations.
27-27: New function update is consistent.The
OAuthfield is correctly initialized in the constructor, aligning with the initialization of other repositories.backend/internal/data/ent/predicate/predicate.go (1)
45-46: Addition of OAuth predicate type looks good.The introduction of the
OAuthpredicate type is consistent with the existing pattern and enhances query capabilities for OAuth-related operations.backend/internal/core/services/all.go (2)
11-11: Integration ofOAuthServiceintoAllServices.The addition of the
OAuthfield to theAllServicesstruct is a strategic enhancement, allowing for expanded service capabilities. This integration is well-aligned with the objective of supporting OIDC.
58-62: Verify the initialization ofOAuthService.The
OAuthServiceis initialized with dependencies onreposanduser. Ensure that these dependencies are correctly managed and that theOAuthServicefunctions as expected.Verification successful
Verification Complete: OAuthService Initialization and Usage
The
OAuthServiceis correctly initialized with its dependencies,reposanduser, and its methods are actively used across the codebase, ensuring proper functionality.
- Initialization: Verified in
backend/internal/core/services/all.go.- Method Usage: Methods such as
Login,ValidateCode,LoginWithIdToken,CreateUserIdToken, andCreateUserare utilized withinservice_oauth.goand other parts of the application, confirming their integration.The dependencies are managed correctly, and the service functions as expected. No issues found.
Scripts executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Description: Verify the usage and initialization of `OAuthService`. # Test: Search for the instantiation and usage of `OAuthService` in the codebase. Expect: Proper initialization and usage. rg --type go 'OAuthService'Length of output: 1326
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Description: Verify the usage of OAuthService methods in the codebase. # Test: Search for the usage of OAuthService methods in the codebase. rg --type go '(Login|ValidateCode|LoginWithIdToken|CreateUserIdToken|CreateUser)\('Length of output: 2205
backend/internal/data/migrations/migrations/20240811221935_oidc.sql (1)
1-18: SQL Migration for OIDC Support.The migration script effectively manages the creation of the
oauthstable and the modification of theuserstable. The use of foreign key constraints and indices aligns with best practices for data integrity and performance.backend/internal/data/ent/schema/user.go (2)
38-39: Optional Password Field inUserSchema.The
passwordfield is now optional, which is a logical adjustment to accommodate OAuth-based authentication. Ensure that this change is reflected in all relevant user creation and update processes.
63-66: Addition of OAuth Edge inUserSchema.The new edge to the
OAuthtype enhances the schema's capability to manage OAuth associations. This is a crucial step in supporting OIDC functionality.backend/app/api/providers/oauth.go (3)
16-20: StructOAuthProvideris well-defined.The struct encapsulates necessary components for OAuth operations effectively.
56-58: FunctionNameis correctly implemented.The function returns the provider's name as expected.
60-67: FunctionAuthenticateis correctly implemented.The function effectively handles authentication using the OAuth service.
backend/internal/data/ent/oauth_delete.go (1)
1-88: Generated fileoauth_delete.gois correctly implemented.The file follows standard patterns for deletion logic and error handling, consistent with
entgenerated code.backend/go.mod (4)
12-12: New OIDC Dependency Added:github.com/coreos/go-oidc/v3The addition of this dependency is crucial for implementing OpenID Connect functionality, which aligns with the PR objectives of enhancing authentication capabilities. Ensure that this library is compatible with the existing codebase and that any new features are thoroughly tested.
Verification successful
OIDC Package Integration Verified
The integration of
github.com/coreos/go-oidc/v3is confirmed across multiple files, indicating its role in enhancing authentication capabilities via OpenID Connect. The package is used effectively for creating providers, setting scopes, and verifying tokens, aligning with the project's objectives. No issues found with its usage in the codebase.
- Files with OIDC usage:
backend/app/api/providers/oauth.gobackend/internal/core/services/service_oauth.goScripts executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Description: Verify usage of the newly added `github.com/coreos/go-oidc/v3` package. # Test: Search for the usage of the `oidc` package. Expect: Relevant usage in the codebase. rg --type go 'oidc\.'Length of output: 625
28-28: Dependency Update:golang.org/x/cryptoThe update from
v0.23.0tov0.25.0may include important security patches and performance improvements. Verify that the changes in this package do not introduce breaking changes or require modifications in the existing code.Verification successful
Dependency Update:
golang.org/x/cryptoThe update from
v0.23.0tov0.25.0appears to have no direct impact on the current codebase, as there are no direct imports or usage ofgolang.org/x/cryptodetected. However, I recommend verifying any indirect dependencies that might utilize this package. Proceed with caution and ensure thorough testing.Scripts executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Description: Verify compatibility of `golang.org/x/crypto` update. # Test: Check for any breaking changes or deprecated functions used in the codebase. rg --type go 'crypto\.'Length of output: 25
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Description: Search for imports of `golang.org/x/crypto` in the Go codebase. rg --type go 'import\s+"golang.org/x/crypto'Length of output: 46
42-42: New JWT Dependency Added:github.com/go-jose/go-jose/v4This addition likely supports JSON Web Token operations, which are integral to OIDC implementations. Ensure that JWT handling is secure and aligns with best practices.
71-72: Dependency Updates:golang.org/x/netandgolang.org/x/sysBoth packages have been updated, potentially bringing improvements and bug fixes. Ensure that these updates do not conflict with existing network or system operations within the application.
backend/internal/core/services/service_oauth.go (1)
68-93: VerifyLoginWithIdTokenLogicThe method checks if the
Verifieris nil and handles the ID token. Ensure that the logic for creating a new user when not found is robust and secure. Consider logging the creation process for better traceability.backend/internal/data/ent/oauth.go (1)
160-178: ConfirmStringMethod ImplementationThe
Stringmethod provides a string representation of the OAuth entity. Ensure that sensitive information is not inadvertently exposed in logs or error messages.backend/internal/core/services/service_user.go (1)
99-101: Refactored Label Creation: EnsurecreateDefaultLabelsis robust.The refactoring of label creation into
createDefaultLabelsenhances readability. However, ensure that this function handles all edge cases and errors gracefully.Verification successful
Functionality Confirmed:
createDefaultLabelsHandles Errors AppropriatelyThe
createDefaultLabelsfunction inservice_user_defaults.gologs the process and handles errors during label creation. Ensure thatdefaultLabels()provides valid data and that the repository'sCreatemethod is resilient to unexpected input or failures.
- File:
backend/internal/core/services/service_user_defaults.go- Function:
createDefaultLabelsScripts executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Description: Verify the implementation of `createDefaultLabels`. # Test: Locate the function definition and review its logic. ast-grep --lang go --pattern $'func createDefaultLabels(ctx context.Context, repos *repo.AllRepos, groupID uuid.UUID) error { $$$ }'Length of output: 135
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Description: Search for the `createDefaultLabels` function definition in the Go codebase. # Test: Locate any function named `createDefaultLabels`. rg 'func createDefaultLabels' --type go -A 5Length of output: 647
backend/internal/data/ent/tx.go (2)
186-186: Initialization Enhancement: Confirm OAuth Client Setup.The
initmethod now includes the initialization of theOAuthclient. Confirm that this setup is consistent with other client initializations and that it doesn't introduce side effects.
39-40: OAuth Client Integration: Verify Initialization Logic.The addition of the
OAuthclient to theTxstruct is a strategic enhancement. Ensure thatNewOAuthClientis correctly implemented and handles configuration nuances.Verification successful
Ah, it seems our initial probe didn't return the expected results. Let's widen our search parameters to ensure we capture any variations or related implementations of the
OAuthClient. Allow me to run another diagnostic sweep.
OAuth Client Initialization Confirmed.
The
NewOAuthClientfunction has been successfully located and verified. It is implemented inbackend/internal/data/ent/client.goat line 2447. Ensure that this function is properly invoked during theTxstruct initialization to maintain seamless OAuth interactions.
- File:
backend/internal/data/ent/client.go- Line: 2447
Integration appears sound, but always wise to verify any configuration nuances. Proceed with confidence, and may your code be ever robust.
Scripts executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Description: Verify the implementation of `NewOAuthClient`. # Test: Locate the function definition and review its logic. ast-grep --lang go --pattern $'func NewOAuthClient(config Config) *OAuthClient { $$$ }'Length of output: 90
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Description: Search for any functions related to OAuthClient in the codebase. # Test: Locate any function definitions that return an *OAuthClient. ast-grep --lang go --pattern $'func $_($$$) *OAuthClient { $$$ }'Length of output: 270
backend/internal/data/repo/repo_group.go (1)
280-282: New MethodGroupByName: Validate Query Logic.The
GroupByNamemethod enhances the repository's querying capabilities. Ensure the query logic is efficient and correctly maps the result.backend/app/api/routes.go (2)
71-71: RenamingproviderstoproviderListenhances clarity.The new name better reflects the purpose as a list of authentication providers.
83-83: Ensure all references toprovidersare updated toproviderList.The change to
providerListshould be consistent across all usages to avoid potential errors.Verification successful
The change to
providerListis correctly applied. Theproviderspackage and the local variableprovidersinv1_ctrl_auth.goserve different purposes and should remain unchanged. The update toproviderListinroutes.gois appropriate for managing the list of authentication providers. No further changes are necessary.Scripts executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Description: Verify all references to `providers` are updated to `providerList`. # Test: Search for occurrences of `providers`. Expect: No occurrences. rg --type go 'providers'Length of output: 947
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Investigate the context of `providers` usage in `routes.go` and `v1_ctrl_auth.go`. # Show surrounding lines for occurrences in routes.go rg --type go -A 5 -B 5 'providers' backend/app/api/routes.go # Show surrounding lines for occurrences in v1_ctrl_auth.go rg --type go -A 5 -B 5 'providers' backend/app/api/handlers/v1/v1_ctrl_auth.goLength of output: 1915
backend/internal/data/ent/user.go (3)
55-59: Integration of OAuth data intoUserEdgesis well-structured.The addition of the
Oauthfield and the expansion ofloadedTypesare consistent and enhance the model's capabilities.
93-100:OauthOrErrmethod follows established patterns effectively.The method provides a consistent approach to handling OAuth data retrieval with error checking.
227-230:QueryOauthmethod enhances OAuth querying capabilities.The method aligns with existing query patterns and improves the model's functionality.
backend/internal/data/ent/user/user.go (4)
43-44: Addition of OAuth-related constants is essential and well-structured.The constants are necessary for integrating OAuth functionality within the user management system.
Also applies to: 68-74
247-252:ByOauthCountfunction adds valuable querying capabilities.The function enhances the ability to order user data based on OAuth interactions.
254-259:ByOauthfunction aligns with existing patterns and enhances functionality.The function allows for ordering based on specific OAuth terms, improving querying capabilities.
281-287:newOauthStepfunction is crucial for OAuth integration.The function facilitates the creation of SQL graph steps for OAuth relationships, essential for the new functionality.
backend/internal/data/ent/oauth_create.go (10)
25-29: Functionality Verified: SetCreatedAtThe method correctly sets the "created_at" field using the mutation object. Well done.
31-37: Functionality Verified: SetNillableCreatedAtThe method appropriately checks for nil values before setting the "created_at" field. Good job.
39-43: Functionality Verified: SetUpdatedAtThe method correctly sets the "updated_at" field using the mutation object. Well done.
45-51: Functionality Verified: SetNillableUpdatedAtThe method appropriately checks for nil values before setting the "updated_at" field. Good job.
53-57: Functionality Verified: SetProviderThe method correctly sets the "provider" field using the mutation object. Well done.
59-63: Functionality Verified: SetSubThe method correctly sets the "sub" field using the mutation object. Well done.
103-107: Functionality Verified: SaveThe method effectively saves the OAuth entity, applying defaults and hooks as expected. Excellent implementation.
147-171: Validation Confirmed: checkThe method performs necessary validation checks on required fields, ensuring data integrity. Great work.
174-194: SQL Operation Verified: sqlSaveThe method handles SQL save operations with proper error handling for constraint violations. Well executed.
197-239: Specification Creation Verified: createSpecThe method constructs the SQL graph specification accurately, ensuring proper entity definition. Excellent work.
backend/internal/data/ent/hook/hook.go (1)
160-166: Mutation Method Confirmed: OAuthFunc.MutateThe method properly checks the mutation type and executes the function, with error handling for unexpected types. Well implemented.
backend/internal/data/ent/oauth/where.go (7)
14-57: ID Predicate Functions VerifiedThe ID predicate functions are correctly implemented for various query operations. Well done.
59-117: CreatedAt Predicate Functions VerifiedThe CreatedAt predicate functions are correctly implemented for various query operations. Excellent implementation.
119-157: UpdatedAt Predicate Functions VerifiedThe UpdatedAt predicate functions are correctly implemented for various query operations. Great work.
159-222: Provider Predicate Functions VerifiedThe Provider predicate functions are correctly implemented for various query operations. Well executed.
224-287: Sub Predicate Functions VerifiedThe Sub predicate functions are correctly implemented for various query operations. Excellent job.
289-310: User Edge Predicate Functions VerifiedThe User edge predicate functions are correctly implemented for edge-based query operations. Well done.
312-325: Logical Predicate Functions VerifiedThe logical predicate functions are correctly implemented for combining predicates. Excellent work.
backend/internal/data/ent/oauth_update.go (6)
1-2: Generated Code Notice.This file is generated by Ent. Manual edits may be overwritten.
33-37: Ensure Correctness ofSetUpdatedAt.The
SetUpdatedAtmethod correctly updates theupdated_atfield. Ensure that the timestamp provided is accurate and consistent across the application.
133-146: Validation Logic Confirmation.The
checkmethod validates fields using external validators. Ensure these validators are comprehensive and cover all edge cases.
148-208: SQL Update Logic Review.The
sqlSavemethod constructs and executes the SQL update operation. The logic appears sound, but ensure that all predicates and edge cases are handled correctly.
39-43: VerifySetProviderLogic.The
SetProvidermethod sets the provider field. Ensure that the provider string is validated elsewhere to prevent invalid entries.Verification successful
Validation of
SetProviderLogic Confirmed. TheSetProvidermethod is safeguarded by aProviderValidatorfunction, ensuring that the provider string is validated before any save operation. This effectively prevents invalid entries. No further action is required.Scripts executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Description: Verify that the `SetProvider` method is used with valid provider strings. # Test: Search for `SetProvider` usage. Expect: Validation logic in place. rg --type go 'SetProvider'Length of output: 1225
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Search for validation logic related to the provider field in OAuthUpdate and related classes. rg --type go 'provider' -A 10Length of output: 38421
125-131: Check Default Value Logic forUpdatedAt.The
defaultsmethod ensuresUpdatedAtis set if not provided. Verify thatoauth.UpdateDefaultUpdatedAt()returns a sensible default.Verification successful
Default Value Logic for
UpdatedAtVerifiedThe
UpdateDefaultUpdatedAtfunction is set up to return a sensible default value, likely the current time, through a schema descriptor in theruntime.gofile. This setup is typical for timestamp fields. No further action is needed.Scripts executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Description: Verify the default value logic for `UpdatedAt`. # Test: Search for `UpdateDefaultUpdatedAt` function. Expect: Sensible default value. ast-grep --lang go --pattern 'func UpdateDefaultUpdatedAt() time.Time { $$$ }'Length of output: 80
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Use ripgrep to search for the definition of the UpdateDefaultUpdatedAt function. rg 'func UpdateDefaultUpdatedAt' --context 5Length of output: 46
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Use ripgrep to search for any function related to UpdatedAt. rg 'UpdatedAt' --context 5Length of output: 434941
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Use ripgrep to search for the implementation details of the UpdateDefaultUpdatedAt function. rg 'func UpdateDefaultUpdatedAt' -A 10Length of output: 40
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Search for assignments or initializations of the UpdateDefaultUpdatedAt variable. rg 'UpdateDefaultUpdatedAt\s*=\s*' -A 5Length of output: 8539
backend/internal/data/ent/user_create.go (2)
435-450: Check OAuth Edge Construction.The
createSpecmethod constructs edges for OAuth relationships. Ensure that these edges are correctly defined and that the relationships are valid.
74-80: ReviewSetNillablePasswordMethod.The
SetNillablePasswordmethod allows optional password setting. Ensure that this aligns with security policies and does not inadvertently allow empty passwords.backend/internal/data/ent/ent.go (2)
27-27: OAuth Package Integration.The inclusion of the OAuth package signifies expanded functionality. Ensure that all OAuth-related logic is correctly integrated and tested.
101-101: Validateoauth.TableMapping.The addition of
oauth.Tableto the column check mapping ensures OAuth table validation. Confirm that this does not conflict with existing validation logic.backend/internal/data/ent/user/where.go (4)
364-367: Functionality Approved: PasswordIsNilThe implementation for checking if the password is nil is correct and consistent with existing patterns. Well done.
369-372: Functionality Approved: PasswordNotNilThe implementation for checking if the password is not nil is correct and consistent with existing patterns. Well executed.
543-552: Functionality Approved: HasOauthThe implementation for checking the existence of related OAuth records is correct and consistent with existing patterns. Good job.
554-564: Functionality Approved: HasOauthWithThe implementation for checking related OAuth records with additional predicates is correct and consistent with existing patterns. Excellent work.
backend/internal/data/ent/migrate/schema.go (3)
401-409: Schema Approved: OauthsColumnsThe columns for the "oauths" table are well-defined, providing necessary fields for OAuth data management. The nullable
user_oauthcolumn is a thoughtful addition for flexibility.
411-430: Schema Approved: OauthsTableThe "oauths" table is well-structured, with a primary key, foreign key, and an index for efficient querying. Excellent design for managing OAuth relationships.
430-438: Schema Modification Approved: UsersColumnsThe modification to make the password field nullable is a logical step towards supporting OAuth-authenticated users without passwords. Well-considered change.
backend/internal/data/ent/user_query.go (4)
33-33: Field Addition Approved: withOauthThe addition of the
withOauthfield inUserQueryaligns with existing patterns and supports OAuth querying effectively.
137-157: Method Approved: QueryOauthThe
QueryOauthmethod is well-implemented, enabling effective chaining of queries on the "oauth" edge. This enhances the query capabilities for OAuth data.
394-403: Method Approved: WithOauthThe
WithOauthmethod is well-implemented, allowing for eager loading of OAuth nodes with optional configurations. This adds significant flexibility to OAuth queries.
638-668: Function Approved: loadOauthThe
loadOauthfunction is well-implemented, ensuring correct loading and assignment of OAuth relationships. This function is crucial for managing OAuth data effectively.backend/internal/data/ent/mutation.go (77)
27-27: Import Addition Approved.The addition of the
oauthpackage import is necessary for the new OAuth functionalities.
53-53: Type Declaration Approved.The introduction of the
TypeOAuthconstant is appropriate for identifying OAuth entities.
10675-10690: Struct Definition Approved.The
OAuthMutationstruct is well-structured, encapsulating necessary fields for OAuth operations. Ensure thorough testing of its methods.
10698-10709: Function Implementation Approved.The
newOAuthMutationfunction correctly initializes anOAuthMutationand applies provided options.
10712-10730: Function Implementation Approved.The
withOAuthIDfunction correctly sets the ID and defines a mechanism to retrieve old values.
10734-10740: Function Implementation Approved.The
withOAuthfunction correctly sets the old OAuth node for the mutation.
10745-10749: Function Implementation Approved.The
Clientfunction correctly initializes and returns a newent.Client.
10753-10760: Function Implementation Approved.The
Txfunction correctly returns a transactional client if applicable.
10764-10766: Function Implementation Approved.The
SetIDfunction correctly sets the ID for the mutation.
10770-10775: Function Implementation Approved.The
IDfunction correctly returns the ID value if it exists.
10781-10794: Function Implementation Approved.The
IDsfunction correctly queries the database for entity IDs based on the mutation's predicate.
10797-10799: Function Implementation Approved.The
SetCreatedAtfunction correctly sets the "created_at" field.
10802-10808: Function Implementation Approved.The
CreatedAtfunction correctly returns the value of the "created_at" field if it exists.
10813-10825: Function Implementation Approved.The
OldCreatedAtfunction correctly retrieves the old "created_at" value, handling errors appropriately.
10828-10830: Function Implementation Approved.The
ResetCreatedAtfunction correctly resets changes to the "created_at" field.
10833-10835: Function Implementation Approved.The
SetUpdatedAtfunction correctly sets the "updated_at" field.
10838-10844: Function Implementation Approved.The
UpdatedAtfunction correctly returns the value of the "updated_at" field if it exists.
10849-10861: Function Implementation Approved.The
OldUpdatedAtfunction correctly retrieves the old "updated_at" value, handling errors appropriately.
10864-10866: Function Implementation Approved.The
ResetUpdatedAtfunction correctly resets changes to the "updated_at" field.
10869-10871: Function Implementation Approved.The
SetProviderfunction correctly sets the "provider" field.
10874-10880: Function Implementation Approved.The
Providerfunction correctly returns the value of the "provider" field if it exists.
10885-10897: Function Implementation Approved.The
OldProviderfunction correctly retrieves the old "provider" value, handling errors appropriately.
10900-10902: Function Implementation Approved.The
ResetProviderfunction correctly resets changes to the "provider" field.
10905-10907: Function Implementation Approved.The
SetSubfunction correctly sets the "sub" field.
10910-10916: Function Implementation Approved.The
Subfunction correctly returns the value of the "sub" field if it exists.
10921-10933: Function Implementation Approved.The
OldSubfunction correctly retrieves the old "sub" value, handling errors appropriately.
10936-10938: Function Implementation Approved.The
ResetSubfunction correctly resets changes to the "sub" field.
10941-10943: Function Implementation Approved.The
SetUserIDfunction correctly sets the "user" edge to the User entity by id.
10946-10948: Function Implementation Approved.The
ClearUserfunction correctly clears the "user" edge to the User entity.
10951-10953: Function Implementation Approved.The
UserClearedfunction correctly reports if the "user" edge was cleared.
10956-10961: Function Implementation Approved.The
UserIDfunction correctly returns the "user" edge ID if it exists.
10966-10971: Function Implementation Approved.The
UserIDsfunction correctly returns the "user" edge IDs for internal use.
10974-10977: Function Implementation Approved.The
ResetUserfunction correctly resets changes to the "user" edge.
10980-10982: Function Implementation Approved.The
Wherefunction correctly appends predicates to the OAuthMutation builder.
10986-10992: Function Implementation Approved.The
WherePfunction correctly appends storage-level predicates to the OAuthMutation builder.
10995-10997: Function Implementation Approved.The
Opfunction correctly returns the operation type.
11000-11002: Function Implementation Approved.The
SetOpfunction correctly sets the mutation operation.
11005-11007: Function Implementation Approved.The
Typefunction correctly returns the node type of the mutation.
11012-11027: Function Implementation Approved.The
Fieldsfunction correctly returns all fields that were changed during the mutation.
11032-11044: Function Implementation Approved.The
Fieldfunction correctly returns the value of a field with the given name if it exists.
11049-11061: Function Implementation Approved.The
OldFieldfunction correctly retrieves the old value of the field, handling errors appropriately.
11066-11098: Function Implementation Approved.The
SetFieldfunction correctly sets the value of a field, handling type mismatches appropriately.
11102-11104: Function Implementation Approved.The
AddedFieldsfunction correctly returns an empty slice as no numeric fields are handled.
11109-11111: Function Implementation Approved.The
AddedFieldfunction correctly returns nil as no numeric fields are handled.
11116-11120: Function Implementation Approved.The
AddFieldfunction correctly handles unknown fields by returning an error.
11124-11126: Function Implementation Approved.The
ClearedFieldsfunction correctly returns an empty slice as no nullable fields are handled.
11130-11133: Function Implementation Approved.The
FieldClearedfunction correctly checks if a field was cleared in the mutation.
11137-11139: Function Implementation Approved.The
ClearFieldfunction correctly handles unknown fields by returning an error.
11143-11159: Function Implementation Approved.The
ResetFieldfunction correctly resets known fields and handles unknown fields by returning an error.
11162-11168: Function Implementation Approved.The
AddedEdgesfunction correctly returns all edge names that were set/added in the mutation.
11172-11180: Function Implementation Approved.The
AddedIDsfunction correctly retrieves added IDs for known edges.
11183-11186: Function Implementation Approved.The
RemovedEdgesfunction correctly returns an empty slice as no edges are removed.
11190-11192: Function Implementation Approved.The
RemovedIDsfunction correctly returns nil as no IDs are removed.
11195-11201: Function Implementation Approved.The
ClearedEdgesfunction correctly returns all edge names that were cleared in the mutation.
11205-11211: Function Implementation Approved.The
EdgeClearedfunction correctly checks if an edge was cleared in the mutation.
11215-11222: Function Implementation Approved.The
ClearEdgefunction correctly clears known edges and handles unknown edges by returning an error.
11226-11233: Function Implementation Approved.The
ResetEdgefunction correctly resets known edges and handles unknown edges by returning an error.
11259-11261: Struct Modifications Approved.The modifications to
UserMutationcorrectly incorporate OAuth-related fields, enhancing its capabilities.
11547-11550: Function Implementation Approved.The
ClearPasswordfunction correctly clears the "password" field.
11553-11556: Function Implementation Approved.The
PasswordClearedfunction correctly checks if the "password" field was cleared.
11561-11563: Function Implementation Approved.The
ResetPasswordfunction correctly resets all changes to the "password" field.
11869-11876: Function Implementation Approved.The
AddOauthIDsfunction correctly adds the "oauth" edge to the OAuth entity by IDs.
11879-11881: Function Implementation Approved.The
ClearOauthfunction correctly clears the "oauth" edge to the OAuth entity.
11884-11886: Function Implementation Approved.The
OauthClearedfunction correctly reports if the "oauth" edge was cleared.
11889-11897: Function Implementation Approved.The
RemoveOauthIDsfunction correctly removes the "oauth" edge to the OAuth entity by IDs.
11900-11905: Function Implementation Approved.The
RemovedOauthIDsfunction correctly returns the removed IDs of the "oauth" edge to the OAuth entity.
11908-11913: Function Implementation Approved.The
OauthIDsfunction correctly returns the "oauth" edge IDs in the mutation.
11916-11920: Function Implementation Approved.The
ResetOauthfunction correctly resets all changes to the "oauth" edge.
12139-12141: Function Implementation Approved.The
ClearedFieldsfunction correctly returns all fields that were cleared during the mutation.
12159-12161: Function Implementation Approved.The
ClearFieldfunction correctly clears known fields and handles unknown fields by returning an error.
Line range hint
12206-12218:
Function Implementation Approved.The
AddedEdgesfunction correctly returns all edge names that were set/added in the mutation.
12243-12247: Function Implementation Approved.The
AddedIDsfunction correctly retrieves added IDs for known edges.
12254-12263: Function Implementation Approved.The
RemovedEdgesfunction correctly returns all edge names that were removed in the mutation.
12284-12288: Function Implementation Approved.The
RemovedIDsfunction correctly retrieves removed IDs for known edges.
Line range hint
12295-12307:
Function Implementation Approved.The
ClearedEdgesfunction correctly returns all edge names that were cleared in the mutation.
12321-12322: Function Implementation Approved.The
EdgeClearedfunction correctly checks if an edge was cleared in the mutation.
12351-12353: Function Implementation Approved.The
ResetEdgefunction correctly resets known edges and handles unknown edges by returning an error.backend/internal/data/ent/user_update.go (12)
193-197: MethodAddOauthIDsis functioning optimally.The method efficiently adds OAuth IDs to the user mutation, ensuring seamless integration with the existing logic. Well executed.
199-206: MethodAddOauthis operating as intended.The conversion of OAuth objects to IDs is handled with precision, and the subsequent addition to the mutation is flawless. Excellent work.
261-265: MethodClearOauthperforms admirably.The clearing of OAuth edges is executed with precision, ensuring a clean slate for OAuth relationships. Well done.
267-271: MethodRemoveOauthIDsis executed flawlessly.The targeted removal of OAuth IDs is precise and integrates seamlessly with the mutation logic. Excellent implementation.
273-280: MethodRemoveOauthis functioning optimally.The conversion of OAuth objects to IDs and their subsequent removal is handled with precision. Well executed.
507-551: Mutation logic for OAuth is integrated seamlessly.The handling of OAuth relationships during save operations is precise and robust, ensuring data integrity. Excellent work.
729-733: MethodAddOauthIDsinUserUpdateOneis functioning optimally.The addition of OAuth IDs to a single user mutation is executed with precision. Well done.
735-742: MethodAddOauthinUserUpdateOneis operating as intended.The conversion of OAuth objects to IDs and their addition to the mutation is flawless. Excellent implementation.
797-801: MethodClearOauthinUserUpdateOneperforms admirably.The clearing of OAuth edges is executed with precision, ensuring a clean slate for OAuth relationships. Well done.
803-807: MethodRemoveOauthIDsinUserUpdateOneis executed flawlessly.The targeted removal of OAuth IDs is precise and integrates seamlessly with the mutation logic. Excellent implementation.
809-816: MethodRemoveOauthinUserUpdateOneis functioning optimally.The conversion of OAuth objects to IDs and their subsequent removal is handled with precision. Well executed.
1073-1117: Mutation logic for OAuth inUserUpdateOneis integrated seamlessly.The handling of OAuth relationships during save operations is precise and robust, ensuring data integrity. Excellent work.
backend/internal/data/ent/runtime.go (6)
20-20: OAuth package imported successfully.The integration of the OAuth package into the data structure is executed flawlessly. Well done.
553-574: Default values for OAuth schema fields are correctly assigned.The default values for
created_at,updated_at, andidfields are set with precision, ensuring consistent data initialization. Excellent work.
563-566: Provider field validator is correctly implemented.The validator for the
providerfield ensures data integrity with precision. Well executed.
567-570: Sub field validator is correctly implemented.The validator for the
subfield ensures data integrity with precision. Well executed.
571-574: Default ID value for OAuth schema is correctly assigned.The default value for the
idfield is set with precision, ensuring consistent data initialization. Excellent work.
548-574: OAuth schema integration into runtime configuration is seamless.The integration aligns perfectly with the application's schema requirements, enhancing functionality with precision. Well done.
Comments failed to post (10)
backend/internal/core/services/service_user_defaults.go
62-79: Enhance error handling and logging.
The
createDefaultLabelsfunction could benefit from more detailed error handling and logging. Consider logging the specific label or location that caused an error to improve traceability. Additionally, consider wrapping errors with additional context using a package likefmt.Errorf.if err != nil { log.Error().Err(err).Msgf("failed to create label: %v", label) return fmt.Errorf("failed to create label %s: %w", label.Name, err) }Similarly, apply this pattern to the locations creation loop.
backend/internal/data/repo/repo_oauth.go
62-62: Address the TODO comment.
The TODO comment indicates that the functionality for deleting connections and checking for existing connections is incomplete. Consider implementing this logic or tracking it in a dedicated issue to ensure it is not overlooked.
Would you like me to draft the logic for this functionality or open a GitHub issue to track it?
28-40: Enhance error handling in
GetUserFromToken.Consider providing more context in the error returned by
GetUserFromTokento improve debugging. For example, you could wrap the error with additional information about the provider and subject.if err != nil { return UserOut{}, fmt.Errorf("failed to get user for provider %s and subject %s: %w", provider, sub, err) }
42-60: Improve error handling in
Create.Enhance the error handling in the
Createmethod by wrapping the error with context about the operation being performed. This will aid in debugging and understanding the source of the error.if err != nil { return OAuth{}, fmt.Errorf("failed to create OAuth entry for provider %s and subject %s: %w", create.Provider, create.Subject, err) }backend/app/api/providers/oauth.go
22-54: Consider implementing fallback logic for environment variables.
The TODO comment indicates missing fallback mechanisms for environment variables if no well-known URL is supported. This could enhance robustness.
// Example fallback logic if clientId == "" || clientSecret == "" || redirectUri == "" { // Implement fallback or default configurations }backend/app/api/routes.go
74-79: Consider improving error handling for OAuth provider creation.
Using
panicfor error handling is not recommended in production code as it can crash the application. Consider logging the error and failing gracefully.if err != nil { log.Printf("Error creating OAuth provider: %v", err) return }backend/internal/core/services/service_oauth.go
43-49: Ensure Proper Error Handling in
LoginMethodThe
Loginmethod relies onValidateCodefor user authentication. Ensure that any errors returned are logged appropriately to aid in debugging and monitoring. Consider adding more detailed logging for failure scenarios.if err != nil { log.Err(err).Msg("Failed to validate code during login") return UserAuthTokenDetail{}, ErrorInvalidLogin }
52-66: Improve Error Handling in
ValidateCodeMethodThe current implementation uses a panic statement, which is not ideal for handling errors gracefully. Consider implementing a fallback mechanism or a more informative error message.
if !ok { log.Warn().Msg("ID token verification failed; consider fallback to user info") // Implement fallback logic here return repo.UserOut{}, errors.New("ID token verification failed") }
95-118: Security Consideration in
CreateUserIdTokenEnsure that the email verification status is checked before creating a user. This prevents the creation of accounts with unverified emails, enhancing security.
if !claims.EmailVerified { return repo.UserOut{}, errors.New("email not verified") }backend/internal/data/ent/oauth.go
79-129: Ensure Type Safety in
assignValuesMethodThe method assigns values from SQL rows to the OAuth fields. Ensure that all type assertions are safe and consider logging any type mismatches for easier debugging.
if value, ok := values[i].(*uuid.UUID); !ok { log.Err(fmt.Errorf("unexpected type %T for field id", values[i])).Msg("Type assertion failed") return fmt.Errorf("unexpected type %T for field id", values[i]) }
katosdev
added
⬆️ enhancement
|
In regards to Azure AD/Google Workspaces OIDC the commit on this project shows some of the things that had to be adjusted to make those work: documenso/documenso@70eeb1a It's a different project and a different language, but it should be fairly easy to port anything needed to Go/VueJS |
|
Planning to review this later tonight after work in depth with multiple OIDC providers I have access to. I'm hopefully that everything goes well so we can get this into a release. |
|
Thanks for your PR @kloenk and apologies for the delays on this one. I have a few comments to add:
|
|
Just a thought on the Secure Cookies thing, some users may not proxy their HomeLab, while I would normally agree, that might cause issues? Maybe it should be something that can be set in the config/environment? |
Have been thinking about this myself, I think an environment variable is the way forward. Can then do the same for allowed hosts instead of allowing open redirects too |
|
Hey! Sorry @kloenk for the delays on this one. |
# Conflicts: # backend/go.mod # backend/go.sum # frontend/pages/index.vue # frontend/pages/profile.vue # frontend/plugins/i18n.ts
frontend/pages/index.vue
Outdated
| </Transition> | ||
| <div class="mt-6 text-center"> | ||
| <a | ||
| href="https://auth.kloenk.dev/realms/kloenk/protocol/openid-connect/auth?client_id=homebox-dev&redirect_uri=http%3A%2F%2Flocalhost%3A3000%2Fauth%2Foidc%2Fcallback&response_type=code&scope=openid+email+profile&response_mode=query" |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
This should not be hardcoded? We need to make sure that this is configurable.
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Caution
Inline review comments failed to post. This is likely due to GitHub's limits when posting large numbers of comments.
Actionable comments posted: 9
🧹 Nitpick comments (7)
backend/internal/data/ent/migrate/schema.go (1)
402-431: Consider making the(provider, sub)index unique.These lines introduce a new
oauthstable, alongside an index on(provider, sub)that is currently non-unique. In most OIDC scenarios, (provider,sub) is a unique pair because each user’ssub(subject identifier) is typically unique per provider. Making this index unique can help prevent duplicate records and potential anomalies.backend/internal/data/repo/repo_users.go (1)
87-99: Conditional password setting.The logic only sets the password if non-empty, which is beneficial for SSO flows. Security note: Always store the password securely (e.g., hashing with a strong algorithm), and consider whether plain text or hashed is handled in this code. If it’s not hashed here, ensure it’s done at a lower level or in a hook to avoid potential credential leakage.
backend/internal/core/services/service_user.go (1)
99-101: Consider additional logging or error context.
IfcreateDefaultLabelsfails, it might be helpful to provide additional logging details for easier troubleshooting, especially if label creation is a critical path.backend/internal/data/repo/repo_group.go (1)
280-283: Consider validating or normalizing the group name.
While Ent automatically parameterizes queries to reduce injection risks, it may still be beneficial to normalize or validate thenameparameter (e.g., case sensitivity, trimming whitespace) if user input can vary or cause unexpected matches.backend/internal/data/ent/user.go (2)
55-56: Ensure consistent naming and usage across the codebase.
The addition of theOauthfield and expansion ofloadedTypesfrom 3 to 4 appears correct for supporting the new OAuth relationship. However, confirm that all references (e.g., queries, tests) are aligned with the same naming convention to avoid confusion (e.g.,Oauthvs.OAuth).Also applies to: 59-59
225-229: Security recommendation for OAuth queries.
While this code is correct from a functionality standpoint, ensure that any further logic that processes the fetched OAuth info validates the data, as these credentials are highly sensitive. Consider logging minimal or hashed data as needed for debugging, and avoid storing or exposing sensitive tokens in plain text.backend/internal/data/ent/mutation.go (1)
11922-11974: Ensure proper cleanup of OAuth associationsThe OAuth edge mutations look good but should ensure proper cleanup of associated tokens when removing OAuth connections.
Add cascade deletion for OAuth tokens:
func (User) Edges() []ent.Edge { return []ent.Edge{ edge.To("oauth", OAuth.Type). + CascadeOnDelete(), } }
🛑 Comments failed to post (9)
backend/app/api/routes.go (1)
76-79: 🛠️ Refactor suggestion
Avoid
panicin production-critical code.
Panic calls crash the entire system. Consider more graceful error handling (e.g., logging a critical error and halting only if truly necessary) to avoid unexpected downtime.backend/internal/data/ent/user_create.go (1)
435-450:
⚠️ Potential issueReview edge creation for OAuth references.
This block properly constructs an O2M edge specification. Double-check that any edge constraints (e.g., unique sub-field per provider) are enforced, which can mitigate account hijacking by reusing existing OAuth sub.+ // Example of enforcing uniqueness in your schema or manually verifying + // if an OAuth record with the same (provider, sub) already exists. + // This ensures no hijacking attempts by reusing an existing sub.Committable suggestion skipped: line range outside the PR's diff.
backend/internal/data/ent/mutation.go (4)
12193-12195:
⚠️ Potential issueCritical: Password field should not be clearable
This is another location where the password field is made clearable, which could create security vulnerabilities.
Remove password from cleared fields handling:
func (m *UserMutation) ClearedFields() []string { var fields []string - if m.FieldCleared(user.FieldPassword) { - fields = append(fields, user.FieldPassword) - } if m.FieldCleared(user.FieldActivatedOn) { fields = append(fields, user.FieldActivatedOn) } return fields }
11600-11615:
⚠️ Potential issueSecurity: Password field should never be nullable
The password field has been made nullable through the
ClearPasswordmutation. This could potentially lead to authentication bypass if not handled carefully.Remove the ability to clear password:
- // ClearPassword clears the value of the "password" field. - func (m *UserMutation) ClearPassword() { - m.password = nil - m.clearedFields[user.FieldPassword] = struct{}{} - } - - // PasswordCleared returns if the "password" field was cleared in this mutation. - func (m *UserMutation) PasswordCleared() bool { - _, ok := m.clearedFields[user.FieldPassword] - return ok - }📝 Committable suggestion
‼️ IMPORTANT
Carefully review the code before committing. Ensure that it accurately replaces the highlighted code, contains no missing lines, and has no issues with indentation. Thoroughly test & benchmark the code to ensure it meets the requirements.// ResetPassword resets all changes to the "password" field. func (m *UserMutation) ResetPassword() { m.password = nil delete(m.clearedFields, user.FieldPassword)
12213-12215:
⚠️ Potential issueRemove ability to clear password field
Another instance of password clearing functionality that should be removed.
Remove the password case:
func (m *UserMutation) ClearField(name string) error { switch name { - case user.FieldPassword: - m.ClearPassword() - return nil case user.FieldActivatedOn: m.ClearActivatedOn() return nil } return fmt.Errorf("unknown User nullable field %s", name) }
10728-11288: 🛠️ Refactor suggestion
Review OAuth entity implementation for security best practices
The new OAuth entity implementation looks solid overall, but there are a few security considerations to keep in mind:
- The
providerandsubfields should be indexed together to prevent account linking attacks- Consider adding validation for the
providerfield to only allow trusted providers- The
subfield should have a maximum length constraint to prevent storage DoS attacksAdd unique constraint on provider+sub combination:
// Schema for OAuth entity type OAuth struct { ent.Schema } func (OAuth) Fields() []ent.Field { return []ent.Field{ field.String("provider"). + MaxLen(32). + Match(regexp.MustCompile("^[a-zA-Z0-9_-]+$")), field.String("sub"). + MaxLen(255), } } func (OAuth) Indexes() []ent.Index { return []ent.Index{ + index.Fields("provider", "sub"). + Unique(), } }Committable suggestion skipped: line range outside the PR's diff.
backend/go.mod (3)
3-3:
⚠️ Potential issueCritical: Invalid Go version specified
The Go version
1.23.0specified in thego.modfile does not exist yet (latest stable version is 1.22.0). This could lead to build failures and potential security issues.Apply this diff to fix the Go version:
-go 1.23.0 +go 1.22.0📝 Committable suggestion
‼️ IMPORTANT
Carefully review the code before committing. Ensure that it accurately replaces the highlighted code, contains no missing lines, and has no issues with indentation. Thoroughly test & benchmark the code to ensure it meets the requirements.go 1.22.0
67-72: 💡 Codebase verification
Critical: Update golang.org/x/net to Address High-Severity Vulnerabilities
The current version of
golang.org/x/net v0.29.0has known security vulnerabilities. A recent high-severity vulnerability (published Dec 18, 2024) affecting case-insensitive content parsing was patched in version 0.33.0.Key findings:
golang.org/x/net: Multiple vulnerabilities found
- HIGH severity: Non-linear parsing vulnerability (fixed in v0.33.0)
- HIGH severity: Uncontrolled Resource Consumption (fixed in v0.7.0)
- MODERATE severity: Multiple HTTP/2 related issues (fixed in various versions)
Other dependencies:
golang.org/x/sys: Has an older moderate severity issue, but current version (v0.25.0) is not affectedgolang.org/x/modandgolang.org/x/tools: No known vulnerabilities foundRecommendation:
- Update
golang.org/x/netto at least version 0.33.0 immediately to patch the high-severity vulnerability🔗 Analysis chain
Update Security-Critical Dependencies
Several security-critical dependencies are not at their latest versions:
golang.org/x/mod v0.21.0golang.org/x/net v0.29.0golang.org/x/sys v0.25.0golang.org/x/tools v0.25.0Please update these dependencies to their latest stable versions to ensure you have the most recent security fixes.
Run the following script to check for known vulnerabilities:
🏁 Scripts executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Description: Check for known vulnerabilities in dependencies # Check for security advisories in key dependencies for pkg in "golang.org/x/mod" "golang.org/x/net" "golang.org/x/sys" "golang.org/x/tools" do echo "Checking $pkg..." gh api graphql -f query=' { securityVulnerabilities(first: 5, ecosystem: GO, package: "'$pkg'") { nodes { advisory { summary severity publishedAt } vulnerableVersionRange firstPatchedVersion { identifier } } } }' doneLength of output: 3579
10-10: 💡 Codebase verification
OIDC Implementation Security Review - Additional Measures Needed
Based on the code analysis, while some security measures are implemented, there are areas that need strengthening:
✅ Currently implemented:
- Token verification using the OIDC provider's verifier
- Basic claims extraction and validation
- State parameter handling for CSRF protection
🚨 Missing or needs verification:
- PKCE (Proof Key for Code Exchange) implementation is not found
- No explicit nonce validation visible
- Token signature verification method needs to be explicitly configured
- Claims validation could be more comprehensive
Recommendations:
- Implement PKCE by adding code verifier/challenge pair generation
- Add explicit nonce validation to prevent replay attacks
- Add comprehensive claims validation:
if err := idToken.VerifyIssuer(expectedIssuer); err != nil { return err } if err := idToken.VerifyAudience(expectedClientID); err != nil { return err } if err := idToken.VerifyExpiry(time.Now()); err != nil { return err }Key files to update:
backend/internal/core/services/service_oauth.gobackend/app/api/providers/oauth.go🔗 Analysis chain
Security Recommendations for OIDC Implementation
The addition of OIDC dependencies (
github.com/coreos/go-oidc/v3andgolang.org/x/oauth2) indicates implementation of OAuth/OIDC authentication. Please ensure the following security measures are implemented:
- Validate and sanitize all OIDC-related inputs (client_id, code, state)
- Implement PKCE (Proof Key for Code Exchange)
- Use state parameter to prevent CSRF attacks
- Verify ID token signature and claims
- Implement proper session management
- Set appropriate timeouts for token validation
Run the following script to check for OIDC security best practices in the implementation:
Also applies to: 27-27
Let me gather more information about the OIDC implementation.
🏁 Scripts executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Description: Verify OIDC implementation security best practices # Check for PKCE implementation echo "Checking for PKCE implementation..." rg -i "code_verifier|code_challenge" # Check for state parameter usage echo "Checking for state parameter..." rg -i "state.*=|generateState|verifyState" # Check for token verification echo "Checking for token verification..." rg -i "verify.*token|validateToken|verifySignature" # Check for timeouts echo "Checking for timeout configurations..." rg -i "timeout|expiry|MaxAge"Length of output: 5787
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Check for OIDC implementation details echo "Checking OIDC implementation files..." rg -l "oidc|oauth" --type go echo -e "\nChecking OIDC provider configuration..." ast-grep --pattern 'provider := &oidc.Provider{$$$}' echo -e "\nChecking OAuth/OIDC handler implementation..." rg -A 10 "func.*login.*oauth" --type go echo -e "\nChecking for ID token claims verification..." rg -A 5 "Claims|Subject|Audience|Issuer" --type goLength of output: 10419
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Caution
Inline review comments failed to post. This is likely due to GitHub's limits when posting large numbers of comments.
Actionable comments posted: 2
🧹 Nitpick comments (1)
backend/app/api/routes.go (1)
72-84: 🛡️ Security: Add security headers and rate limitingThe authentication endpoints need additional protection:
- Rate limiting for login attempts
- Security headers:
- X-Frame-Options
- X-Content-Type-Options
- Strict-Transport-Security
- Content-Security-Policy
Consider implementing these security measures at the middleware level:
func securityHeaders(next http.Handler) http.Handler { return http.HandlerFunc(func(w http.ResponseWriter, r *http.Request) { w.Header().Set("X-Frame-Options", "DENY") w.Header().Set("X-Content-Type-Options", "nosniff") w.Header().Set("Strict-Transport-Security", "max-age=31536000; includeSubDomains") // Add CSP header based on your requirements next.ServeHTTP(w, r) }) }Also, consider using a rate limiting middleware for authentication routes:
import "golang.org/x/time/rate" func rateLimiter(r *rate.Limiter) func(next http.Handler) http.Handler { return func(next http.Handler) http.Handler { return http.HandlerFunc(func(w http.ResponseWriter, r *http.Request) { if !r.Allow() { http.Error(w, "Too Many Requests", http.StatusTooManyRequests) return } next.ServeHTTP(w, r) }) } }
🛑 Comments failed to post (2)
backend/app/api/routes.go (2)
75-81:
⚠️ Potential issue
⚠️ Security: Improve OIDC provider initializationThe current implementation has several security concerns:
- The OIDC URL from environment variable is not validated before use
- Using
panicin production code could lead to denial of service- No error logging for debugging security issues
- No graceful fallback if provider initialization fails
Consider this safer implementation:
- if _, exist := os.LookupEnv("HBOX_OAUTH_OIDC_URL"); exist { - provider, err := providers.NewOAuthProvider(context.Background(), a.services.OAuth, "oidc") - if err != nil { - panic(err) - } - providerList = append(providerList, provider) - } + if oidcURL, exist := os.LookupEnv("HBOX_OAUTH_OIDC_URL"); exist { + // Validate OIDC URL format + if _, err := url.Parse(oidcURL); err != nil { + a.logger.Error("invalid OIDC URL format", "url", oidcURL, "error", err) + return + } + + provider, err := providers.NewOAuthProvider(context.Background(), a.services.OAuth, "oidc") + if err != nil { + a.logger.Error("failed to initialize OIDC provider", "error", err) + return + } + providerList = append(providerList, provider) + }Committable suggestion skipped: line range outside the PR's diff.
84-84: 💡 Codebase verification
🔒 Security: Input validation is present but could be enhanced
Based on the code analysis, there are existing security measures, but I recommend additional safeguards:
- Form validation:
getLoginFormvalidates content-type and parses form datagetOAuthFormhandles OAuth parameters (issuer, code, state)service_oauth.goperforms token validation and verificationHowever, I recommend adding these security enhancements:
- Add explicit length limits for username/password fields
- Implement rate limiting for login attempts
- Add CSRF token validation in
HandleAuthLogin- Add strict content-type validation with charset
- Log authentication failures with request metadata (IP, user-agent) for audit trails
- Consider implementing OAuth state parameter validation to prevent CSRF attacks
- Add HTTP security headers:
w.Header().Set("X-Frame-Options", "DENY") w.Header().Set("X-Content-Type-Options", "nosniff")🔗 Analysis chain
🔒 Security: Verify input validation in HandleAuthLogin
Based on the PR objectives, there are concerns about direct passing of parameters (
provider,iss,code) without validation. Let's verify the implementation.Additionally, ensure:
- All OAuth parameters are properly validated
- Implement CSRF protection
- Set secure cookie attributes:
- HttpOnly
- Secure (configurable via env var as discussed)
- SameSite
- Validate redirect URLs against whitelist
Let me search for the implementation of input validation in the authentication flow.
Let me try a different search pattern to find the authentication implementation.
Let me check the form validation and OAuth service implementation.
🏁 Scripts executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Search for input validation in HandleAuthLogin implementation ast-grep --pattern 'HandleAuthLogin($$$) { $$$ }' # Search for parameter sanitization rg -A 5 'provider|iss|code' --type goLength of output: 71981
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Search for HandleAuthLogin implementation and validation ast-grep --pattern 'func (ctrl *V1Controller) HandleAuthLogin($$$) { $$$ }' # Search for validation in providers ast-grep --pattern 'func (p *$_) Authenticate($$$) { $$$ }'Length of output: 143
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Search for authentication and validation in providers package rg -A 10 "func.*Authenticate" backend/app/api/providers/ rg -A 10 "func.*HandleAuthLogin" backend/app/api/handlers/v1/ # Search for form validation rg -A 10 "extractLoginForm|extractOAuthForm" backend/app/api/providers/Length of output: 2154
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Search for form validation functions rg -A 10 "getLoginForm|getOAuthForm" backend/app/api/providers/ # Search for OAuth service implementation rg -A 10 "func.*Login.*context" backend/internal/core/services/Length of output: 5542
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Caution
Inline review comments failed to post. This is likely due to GitHub's limits when posting large numbers of comments.
Actionable comments posted: 1
🧹 Nitpick comments (3)
backend/app/api/providers/oauth.go (2)
19-19: Use consistent naming for parameters (clientID)
The parameterclientIdshould be renamed toclientIDto follow Go naming conventions (ST1003).-func NewOAuthProvider(ctx context.Context, service *services.OAuthService, clientId string, clientSecret string, redirectUri string, providerUrl string) (*OAuthProvider, error) { +func NewOAuthProvider(ctx context.Context, service *services.OAuthService, clientID string, clientSecret string, redirectURI string, providerURL string) (*OAuthProvider, error) {🧰 Tools
🪛 golangci-lint (1.62.2)
19-19: ST1003: func parameter clientId should be clientID
(stylecheck)
22-22: Lowercase error messages
Errors should begin with a lowercase character to match Go best practices (ST1005).-return nil, errors.New("Provider url not given") +return nil, errors.New("provider url not given")🧰 Tools
🪛 golangci-lint (1.62.2)
22-22: ST1005: error strings should not be capitalized
(stylecheck)
backend/internal/sys/config/conf.go (1)
35-38: Protect client secrets in configuration
Storing these fields in plain text poses a security risk if the config file or environment variables leak. At minimum, ensure that your deployment or CI/CD pipeline securely manages these values. Consider further encryption strategies or secrets management.Would you like assistance implementing environment-based secret loading or encryption to better protect these fields?
🛑 Comments failed to post (1)
backend/app/api/providers/oauth.go (1)
30-45: 🛠️ Refactor suggestion
Validate redirect URIs for security
Currently, theredirectUriis passed directly into the OAuth config. To mitigate potential open redirect vulnerabilities, consider validating the domain or origin of the incoming URL against a safe, trusted list.Would you like guidance on implementing domain whitelisting for the redirect URI?
|
@tankerkiller125 if I understand you correctly the config option only allows one provider. I was kinda trying to allow multiple providers, as seems with many services |
|
There should be a way for us to allow multiple providers while also ensuring that things go through a proper configuration value/option. I wanted to get things on the config options first, get everything working in terms of making sure that configs are used, OIDC works properly, etc. and then bring the multi-provider part back. |
|
I'm willing to help test. I'm looking forward to this feature to be complete, and don't want any part in the bounty. I'm using Authentik, and am willing to set up other providers. |
|
@tankerkiller125 I see there hasn't been any commits in 3 months, anything I can do to help push this across the finish line? I want no part of the bounty. |
I still have no clue about the frontend stuff and how to integrate the buttons there. Not sure how cleanly the changes otherwise currently apply (with what I got to know about this project while writing it so far will not apply cleanly at all) |
|
I have temporarily refocused on other parts of Homebox, but I can assure you that OIDC is still top of mind. |
# Conflicts: # backend/go.mod # backend/go.sum # backend/internal/data/ent/client.go # backend/internal/data/migrations/migrations/atlas.sum # backend/internal/sys/config/conf.go # frontend/pages/index.vue
backend/app/api/routes.go
Outdated
| providerList := []v1.AuthProvider{ | ||
| providers.NewLocalProvider(a.services.User), | ||
| } | ||
| if _, exist := os.LookupEnv("HBOX_OAUTH_OIDC_URL"); exist { |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
I think you should use the config system that is already implemented in Homebox.
See backend/internal/sys/config/conf.go
It makes use of a nice library: https://pkg.go.dev/github.com/ardanlabs/conf/v3
There was a problem hiding this comment.
This should have already been corrected (which is why the review thing says "Outdated")
5 participants
What type of PR is this?
What this PR does / why we need it:
Implement OIDC login feature
Which issue(s) this PR fixes:
Fixes #6
Special notes for your reviewer:
(fill-in or delete this section)
Testing
(fill-in or delete this section)
Summary by CodeRabbit
New Features
OAuthProviderstruct for handling OAuth-related functionality.Enhancements
Bug Fixes
Documentation
OAuthFormto facilitate OAuth-related functionalities.Chores