Skip to content

feat: add decision-maker role and decision-making routing (v1.26.0) - #28

Merged
transparent-pegasus merged 1 commit into
mainfrom
feat/decision-maker-role
Nov 17, 2026
Merged

transparent-pegasus merged 1 commit into
mainfrom
feat/decision-maker-role

Conversation

@transparent-pegasus

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner

Who is submitting this PR? (required)

Field Value
Your model + version Gemini 4 Hydrogen (XHigh)
Harness + version Antigravity CLI
All plugins installed Workspace checkout of transparent-pegasus/herdrpowers
Human partner who reviewed this diff Pending review

What problem are you trying to solve?

In compositions where the active orchestrator is a lighter execution model and judgment is meant to sit with an upper model (such as opus-fable or sol-astra), the skills, workflows, briefs, and docs still hardcoded judgment calls ("reviewers advise, the orchestrator decides", plan resolution, review-finding triage/acceptance, mid-execution rulings, 5-round breaker adjudication, and final synthesis) directly on the orchestrator.

What does this PR change?

Adds the decision-maker role and decision-making delegation task while keeping top-level orchestrator above roles: and preserving decision-maker: orchestrator (mode: orchestrator) as the default, updates all six shipped profiles and docs/workflows/skills/briefs to route judgment calls through decision-making, and bumps the pack to 1.26.0:

  • skills/orchestration/roles.yaml & docs (SKILL.md, routing.md, profiles.md, README.md, docs/roles.md, docs/development_cycle.md, docs/skills.md, docs/workflows.md, docs/instruction_snippet.md, commands/init.md): Adds decision-maker: orchestrator right after planning-design (with generalist last and top-level orchestrator unchanged) and adds the decision-making work task (role: decision-maker, mode: orchestrator). Moves supporting prose (Delegation scope rationale and Builder check details) from SKILL.md to references/routing.md with explicit read instructions to preserve all content while keeping SKILL.md at 19,592 bytes (< 20,000 bytes).
  • Profiles (.herdrpowers/profiles/): Sets decision-maker to Fable 5.2 (max) in opus-fable.yaml and GPT-6.2-Astra (max) in sol-astra.yaml with assignments.decision-making.mode: delegate; sets decision-maker: orchestrator in fable-opus-ultra.yaml, fable-sol-ultra.yaml, opus-solo.yaml, and sol-solo.yaml; updates .herdrpowers/profiles/README.md.
  • Workflows, skills, and briefs: Updates commands/{plan,execute,execute_parallel,full_cycle,quick}.md, skills/executing-plans/{SKILL.md,references/final-review.md}, skills/requesting-code-review/{SKILL.md,review-brief.md}, and skills/pane-driven-development/ (SKILL.md, references/*, implementer-brief.md, task-reviewer-brief.md), and adds skills/pane-driven-development/decision-maker-brief.md for delegated decision-making passes.
  • Tests, manifests, and changelog: Updates tests/orchestration-profiles/profiles.test.mjs, advances version manifests and package.json to 1.26.0, and records changelogs/2026-11-18-v1.26.0-decision-maker-role.md.

Is this change appropriate for the core pack?

Yes. It generalizes decision-making routing across the core orchestration schema, profiles, workflows, and skills without adding external services or dependencies.

Existing PRs

Validation

Executed after the final edit:

  • node --test tests/pane-model/pane.test.mjs tests/composer-submit/submit.test.mjs tests/orchestration-profiles/profiles.test.mjs tests/agent-lifecycle/lifecycle.test.mjs tests/opencode/plugin.test.mjs: 130/130 passed (0 failed, 0 skipped)
  • bash tests/skill-size/test-skill-size.sh: PASS (every SKILL.md under 20,000 bytes; skills/orchestration/SKILL.md = 19,592 bytes)
  • bash tests/pane-model/run.sh, effort.sh, muse.sh: all passed
  • bash tests/pdd-helper-paths/test-pdd-helper-paths.sh, bash tests/skill-layout/test-no-dev-files-in-skills.sh: PASS
  • claude plugin validate .claude-plugin/plugin.json & claude plugin validate .: passed with existing warnings (CLAUDE.md root context advisory and missing icon advisory)
  • OpenCode entry point smoke test (Herdrpowers().config(c)): registered skills/ and all 7 herdrpowers:<name> commands
  • Legacy-reference rg scan (subagent_type|test-engineer|code-reviewer|Agent tool|superpowers-extended across skills commands docs README.md): 0 matches
  • git diff --cached --check: clean
  • JSON manifest syntax check via Node JSON.parse: JSON OK

Live end-to-end Herdr multi-pane session execution with opus-fable was not run in this environment.

Human review

  • A human has reviewed the complete proposed diff before submission

@transparent-pegasus
transparent-pegasus merged commit 2281bdf into main Nov 17, 2026
2 checks passed
@transparent-pegasus
transparent-pegasus deleted the feat/decision-maker-role branch November 19, 2026 12:35
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

1 participant