-
Notifications
You must be signed in to change notification settings - Fork 25
Meetingminutes Minutes07032018
Bob Relyea edited this page Mar 4, 2025
·
1 revision
- Roll call (Bob) - quorum achieved.
- Roll call
- Review / approval of the agenda
- Review of previous meeting minutes (February 7, 2018)
- V3.0 Items (Other business to be covered in the following meetings)
- Review Spec V3 from Chris Z
- Review Mechanisms V3 form Chris Z
- Planning for review/complete
- Proposal - Salsa20 & CHaCHa20 - Stef M
- Proposal - Blake2b - Stef M
- Proposal - X3DH & DoubleRatchet - Stef M
- Proposal - XEDDSA signateur mechanism - Stef M
- Revisit Function names
- Comment on comments list (Girish Kumar, CKA_TRUSTED). (Tony C) (https://lists.oasis-open.org/archives/pkcs11-comment/201709/msg00000.html)
- Comments list query (Timo Teras, ETSI TS 103 097 certificates)
- Letter to NIST regarding AES GCM IV generation (Tony)
- PKCS#11 Repository (Tony C)
- PKCS#11 F2F Meeting (April 11 2018)
- New business
- Next meeting
- Call for late arrivals
- Adjourn
- Tim moved, Gerry seconded. No objections, comments or abstentions. Agenda approved.
- February 21, 2018
- Greg moved. Daniel seconded. No objections, comments or abstentions. Minutes approved.
- no updates from Chris, or discussions or questions today.
- Bob: any more comments on these proposals? Stef submitted updates. Bob reviewed and had no more comments, hopefully Stef will be able to make the next meeting and we can discuss.
- Stef (Late arrival): no additional comments.
- Tim moves to open a ballot to include Salsa20 and CHaCha20 in version 3.0, once Bob provides the identifiers. Gerry seconded. Any comments, objections or abstentions? None heard, motion approved to open a ballot once Bob provides the identifiers and Stef uploads the updated proposal.
- Tim moves to open a ballot to include Blake2b in version 3.0, once Bob provides the identifiers. Stef seconded. Any comments, objections or abstentions? None heard, motion approved to open a ballot once Bob provides the identifiers and Stef uploads the updated proposal.
- Stef: There may be an update coming, the name may change and a new mechanism. A general update to EDSA
- Tim: if those get changed, new name and new mechanism would be a new proposal. Bob agrees. This proposal is complete as stands.
- Valerie: Are we talking about which proposal?
- Bob: All three of Stef's proposals together.
- Tim: I see them as a collection, just waiting for Stef to make sure there were no further updates. Should ballot them separately so TC members can voice their opinions on each.
- Stef: No more comments received, no updates planned.
- Tim moves to open a ballot to include XEDDSA signateur mechanism in version 3.0, once Bob provides the identifiers. Stef seconded. Any comments, objections or abstentions? None heard, motion approved to open a ballot once Bob provides the identifiers and Stef uploads the updated proposal.
- Tim moves to open a ballot to include X3DH and DoubleRatchet in version 3.0, once Bob provides the identifiers. Stef seconded. Any comments, objections or abstentions? None heard, motion approved to open a ballot once Bob provides the identifiers and Stef uploads the updated proposal.
- Bob & Tim: did we decide to make these changes? Tim and Bob did not agree with discussion on Feb 21, 2018. Bob & Tim said there were other inconsistencies that were addressed since April 15, 2015. Bob & Tim thinks TC misread 15 April 2015 minutes.
- Valerie suggests co-chairs sync and come back to TC for discussion.
- Tim & Bob note that they were very careful that these functions do not look like the other functions, because they were not.
- Daniel had suggested over email that they could be changed to have the same prefix, yet still different.
- Tim believes they will still be obvious to new developers.
- Valerie wants to clarify that she didn't mean someone new from 2.40 to 3.00 - but new to PKCS#11. Tim said they should still be very different. Daniel noted that "Message" in the name should make it clear.
- Bob will connect with Tony and bring this back to TC.
Comment on comments list (Girish Kumar, CKA_TRUSTED). (Tony) (https://lists.oasis-open.org/archives/pkcs11-comment/201709/msg00000.html)
- deferred
- deferred (awaiting Tony's mail to list)
- waiting to hear back from Tony.
- Tony to present at next meeting hopefully, did upload the slides.
- Bob: the repo has been moved, more details next week.
- Tim: We should probably get the unofficial one removed. Bob: only really me and Chris were using it. Tim: It's public, should be removed.
- Valerie takes action to update wiki to point to official one.
- We have a date, but still no location.
- Bob has backup room saved, but not ideal due to office being busy that week.
- Valerie: Valerie will work with Tony & Bob on a possible joint dinner with KMIP TC.
- March 21, 2018
- Stef, Indra
- Gerry moved. Greg seconded. No objections, comments or abstentions. Adjourned.