Skip to content

TC Meeting Minutes20251119

Jump to bottom Edit New page
John Gray edited this page Nov 19, 2025 · 2 revisions

November 19, 2025 Meeting Minutes

Meeting commenced 4:00 PM EST

  • Roll call taken by Bob R, quorum achieved.
  • John Gray took minutes.

Attendance

  • Tim Hudson, Rob Relyea, John Gray, Mike Markovitz, Darren Johnson, Deepak Gupta, Hamish Cameron, Richard Kettlewell, Scott Marshall, simo, Tony Cox,

  • Review / approval of the agenda

    • Hamish Moved, Michael 2nd. Approved.

  • Approve Minutes (November 5, 2025)

    • Hamish Moved, John Second. Approved.

  • PKCS#11 v3.2 - Statements of Use

    • Ballot passed without issue. So far two statement of works. Need one more.
    • Question on whether it is a legal statement. In past some people have had their legal look at it.
    • Question of where the 2 came from: Answer: One is from Jonathon and one from outside the TC.
    • Hamish has one that is currently with legal team.
    • Tim Hudson says Cryptsoft can make a statement of use if needed.

  • PKCS#11 v3.3

    • External Mu
      • Simo helped get it into shape. No change on the second part of generate Mu. PR comment from an external person to be addressed.
      • Some people want to model it as a Digest algorithm.
    • Hash Restructuring
      • This is mostly editorial restructuring, but there were a few things added.
      • No objections to merge it in.
      • Simo will Merge it
    • Composite Signatures
    • KMAC
      • There is a Pull request for Proposing a KMAC Mechanism
      • Will wait to Merge as it conflicts with the Hash restructuring
      • Discussion on the name XoHash vs XofHash
      • Discussion of proposing C_DigestXofInit C_DigestXofUpdate C_DigestXofExtract C_DigestXofFinal
      • Action: Document to be update with the updated names, and everyone to look at the text. Will vote on this next week.

  • Classification GH Issues with no milestone.

    • A separate group will look at the items that should be closed. Tim, Bob and Valerie
    • Action: Valerie to set up meeting to go through the list.

  • New Business

    • Issues when trying to use CKM_PUB_KEY_FROM_PRIV_KEY (Issues #56 and #57).
    • Discussed at the meeting, and its ready for review.

  • Next Meeting

    • December 3rd. Motion Jonathon, Michael 2nds. Approved.

  • Call for late arrivals

    • Valerie, Jonathon

  • Adjourn

    • Motion to Adjorn. Moved by Simo, Jonathon 2nd. Approved.
Add a custom footer
Add a custom sidebar

Clone this wiki locally